E.L.F Brow Gel

ELF brow gel is an affordable eyebrow gel offering light to medium hold with options for clear or tinted formulas, ideal for everyday natural brow definition without breaking the bank.

See Product

We may earn a small commission if you click our link. It helps support the cost of running our analysis and keeping this site independent.

Rankings by Sentiment Analysis

Reddit Rank

Total Upvotes

455

Editorial Summary: Cheap and cheerful brow gel that mostly works but hold ain't strong; might flake or feel sticky. Great for everyday use if you ain't got wild brows or want a budget dupe. Clear gel is popular for no-flake hold. Not everyone's fave but hard to beat price-wise.

Pros

✓Very affordable compared to prestige brands
✓Good for light hold and natural look
✓Clear gel variant holds brows without flaking
✓Some formulas add volume with fibers
✓Works well for everyday use and layering

Cons

✗Hold often weak, doesn't last all day
✗Can leave white flakes or residue
✗Some find it greasy or oily
✗Not effective for very stubborn or thick brows
✗Gel can pill or feel sticky after drying

Methodology: Analyzed 100 Reddit quotes from various beauty and makeup communities up to 2024, synthesizing key themes on performance, hold, texture, and value of ELF brow gel products.

Asked by Redditors

Does ELF brow gel hold brows all day?

Many users find the hold light to medium and not all-day lasting, especially for stubborn brows.

Does ELF brow gel leave white flakes?

Some users report white flakes or residue after drying, though others don't experience this.

Is ELF brow gel a good dupe for higher-end brands?

Yes, many consider ELF a solid affordable dupe for pricier brands like Benefit and Anastasia.

Are there different types of ELF brow gels?

Yes, ELF offers clear gels, tinted gels like Wow Brow, and laminating gels with varying hold strengths.

Can ELF brow gel be greasy or oily?

A few users noticed greasiness or melting off, sometimes related to skincare routine.

Reddit Reviews:

Calculated by the the number of posts or comments that have an opinion on this product

Positive

Neutral

Negative

Elf wow brow gel in deep brown

u/Pristine-Drink-708Sentiment: likely neutral Upvotes: 1443

ELF Wow Brow isn't super crunchy, but it's definitely not as soft. But I can't really tell unless I'm feeling with my fingers, so for $4, that itself is not a dealbreaker. However, Boy Brow also seems to leave a cleaner look, while Wow Brow makes my brow look slightly bushier. Also, I use one layer with Boy Brow then finish with a spoolie, but with Wow Brow I had to put 2-3 (not sure if this is bc it's brown though). Overall, I still kinda like Boy Brow more, but for $4, I'd get Wow Brow again.

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely neutral Upvotes: 112

So far, I like it! It's pretty close to the Boy Brow for me, although Boy Brow is a teeny bit darker because I get that one in Black. I think next time I'll go for the "Deep Brown" shade in ELF and see how that goes.

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 112

My favorite eyebrow gel is ELF’s Brow Gel. Strictly bc of the cost lol

u/b0toxBettySentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 55

When I use the elf brow gel, at first my brows looks great when I brush them up and shape them but it doesn’t last and hold. I don’t care if it’s drugstore or prestige brand, I need a recommendation for the best holding clear brow gel, please! Does one even exist or do they all wear off?

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 55

The elf wow brow gel in taupe! It took me probably 6 months to use up the old one (which is indeed the shelf life of the product), but that was with on and off use. Just got the new one today after limping the old one along for a little while! It's a little dark on me since my brows are quite blond, but don't really know any other good brow gels at this price range so if anyone has any recs for me to try let me know 🙏

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely neutral Upvotes: 51

ELF Eyebrow Gel for sleek, defined brows that stay in place all day.

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 24

Buy the elf version next time! Better, $5 and don’t peel off :)

u/BolamedrosaSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 22

ELF has a clear lash and brow gel for only $3!

u/EmTerreriSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 21

I just got it for $6 in the us at ulta. Seems like a fair price to me since imo it’s as good as benefit gimme brow which is $26 for less product

u/JaneAustenite17Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 18

Currently Showing 10 Reviews