glossier lash stick

Glossier Lash Slick is a tubing mascara that effortlessly lengthens and separates lashes for a natural, smudge-proof look with easy removal.

See Product

We may earn a small commission if you click our link. It helps support the cost of running our analysis and keeping this site independent.

Rankings by Sentiment Analysis

Reddit Rank

Total Upvotes

175

Editorial Summary: Glossier Lash Slick is the go-to if you want natural length and no smudging, perfect for an everyday barely-there look. The small wand is a winner for precise application. Heads up though, recent formula changes got some fans bummed. Not the mascara for dramatic volume, but great if you want simple and clean.

Pros

✓Natural, subtle look with good lash separation and lengthening
✓No smudging or flaking, stays put during activities like hot yoga
✓Easy to remove compared to other mascaras, tubing formula
✓Available in black and true brown shades for varied looks
✓Small plastic wand allows precise application

Cons

✗Recent reformulation reportedly worse than original formula
✗Less volume compared to other mascaras, too minimal for some
✗Requires more rubbing to remove, potential lash fallout
✗Not ideal for dramatic looks, better for everyday subtle use
✗Some users experienced clumping when new

Methodology: Analyzed 13 user quotes from Reddit across 13 subreddits including AsianBeauty, Sephora, MakeupAddiction, and 30PlusSkinCare, spanning January 2016 to June 2025, focusing on consumer experiences with Glossier Lash Slick mascara.

Asked by Redditors

Is Glossier Lash Slick waterproof?

It is a tubing mascara that resists smudging and flaking but removes easily with warm water, not technically waterproof.

Does Glossier Lash Slick come in colors?

Yes, it is available in black and a true brown shade for a natural look.

How do I remove Glossier Lash Slick mascara?

It removes easily with warm water and gentle rubbing, but some users find it requires more effort.

Is the recent Glossier Lash Slick formula different?

Yes, many users report the reformulated version is less effective than the original.

Is Glossier Lash Slick good for volume?

It provides subtle volume but is better known for lengthening and natural separation rather than dramatic volume.

Reddit Reviews:

Calculated by the the number of posts or comments that have an opinion on this product

Positive

Neutral

Negative

Glossier Lash Slick: Very natural mascara. You get the benefit of tubing mascara without it looking heavy/spidery. Separate lashes really well and lengthens.

u/froyoandsushiSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 76

i also really like the nonAB glossier lash slick for a little more volume

u/dogsimpSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 70

For a stick- glossier future dew solid

u/sameee15Sentiment: likely neutral Upvotes: 9

I have the brown Glossier one, which I like to use when I want a more natural look.

u/OnePea6602Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 7

My fave is glossier lash slick, subtle but lengthening, no flaking or smudging, easy to remove, perfect small plastic wand... but I'm finding out on their subreddit that it's been reformulated since they joined Sephora. Big sad.

u/hibiki_minajSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 7

Glossier Lash Slick is my mascara holy grail for not smudging or flaking. I also only use it on my top lashes.

u/jax2loveSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 5

Glossier before they reformulated it (I haven’t tried the new formula but I’ve heard bad things). Doesn’t clump, thickens and elongates, stays on all day without smudging, removes easily. One time I was hanging out with my friends while wearing it and someone said something really funny while I was taking a sip of water. I choked on the water for like 30 seconds trying not to spit it all over my friend’s couch, life flashing before my eyes, tears running down my face. I checked my mascara after and it was legit flawless.

u/jukeboxgasolineSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 3

I have the brown Glossier one, which I like to use when I want a more natural look.

u/verycoolbutterflySentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 3

I personally didn’t like the Caliray mascara. It was very flaky and smudgy and it burned my eyes. The whole point of tubing mascara for me is that it works well but also comes off without makeup remover, and this one didn’t do that for me. I used to use the glossier tubing mascara which was a bit more natural, but I’ve recently switched back to Tartelette because it provides waaay more volume and length for a more dramatic look. I am currently trying out the XL version and it’s quite good, definitely more volume I think. I do find it tends to clump a bit when I first use a new tube. After some use it dries out a bit and becomes much more workable. The Tartelette comes off immediately if I wet my fingers with warm water and gently rub my eyelashes between my fingers. The glossier mascara required more rubbing and I found it caused some of my eyelashes to come with it. Since switching to Tarte again, I haven’t lost a single lash.

u/kitkattaSentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 1

Glossier!!! The brown is a nice warm shade and it stays put even during hot yoga.

u/takeyoursupplementsSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 1

Currently Showing 10 Reviews