Maybelline Sky High Mascara

Maybelline Sky High is a drugstore mascara known for delivering impressive lash length and curl hold with a flexible silicone wand, available in waterproof and tinted formulas for versatile, long-lasting wear.

See Product

We may earn a small commission if you click our link. It helps support the cost of running our analysis and keeping this site independent.

Rankings by Sentiment Analysis

Reddit Rank

Total Upvotes

2430

Editorial Summary: Sky High is legit for length and curl, pretty cheap too but brush and formula are hit or miss depending on your lashes. Some swear by it, others find it clumpy or smudgy. Waterproof version helps oily lids. Overall, solid if you like length over volume.

Pros

✓Gives impressive length and curl hold
✓Doesn't smudge or flake easily for many users
✓Affordable drugstore price point
✓Works well as both mascara and brow gel
✓Available in waterproof and tinted options

Cons

✗Brush can be too thin, bendy, or big for some users
✗Formula is sometimes too wet, causing smudging or clumping
✗May not hold curl all day, especially on oily lids
✗Difficult to remove for some, requiring specific removers
✗Formula and performance inconsistent over time

Methodology: Analyzed 91 Reddit user quotes from 13 beauty-related subreddits including MakeupAddiction, Sephora, and beautytalkph between January 2016 and June 2025, synthesizing common themes and opinions about Maybelline Sky High mascara.

Asked by Redditors

Does Maybelline Sky High hold curl well?

It generally holds curl well for several hours, but may struggle on very oily lids or after long wear for some users.

Is this mascara waterproof?

Yes, it comes in waterproof and non-waterproof versions to suit different preferences.

How easy is it to remove?

Removal can be tricky for some; tubing technique or dual-phase removers help ease removal.

Does it add volume as well as length?

It excels at lengthening lashes but some users find it lacks significant volume.

Is the brush easy to use?

Brush design is silicone and flexible but some find it too thin or bendy, causing application challenges.

Reddit Reviews:

Calculated by the the number of posts or comments that have an opinion on this product

Positive

129

Neutral

Negative

Maybelline sky high P449 - 10/10. ang ganda nito 😭😭 no panda eyes and nag sstay talaga curl ng lashes ko kahit buong araw pa yan. sa ibang mascara after a long day nawawala na talaga yung curl. i've always blamed it on my lashes, yun pala pangit lang previous mascara ko. huhu kaso ang sakit nito sa bulsa ha 🥹🥹 love na love ko to kaso i'm gonna try looking for dupes na mas mura kasi di ko majustify yung 449 para sa mascara lang

u/OPSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 1060

Maybelline Sky High Mascara in Brownish Black

u/OPSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 678

Maybelline Sky High Tinted Lash Primer and Waterproof Mascara (black)

u/OPSentiment: likely neutral Upvotes: 226

Best mascara forever to me is maybellene sky high 🩷

u/Willing_Reaction_381Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 186

Maybelline sky high! It quadruples my lashes in volume and proves nice length. I use one coat of the waterproof to hold curl and then go in with the regular in true brown. It also doesn’t smudge on me. My only peeve is that the tube does dry out pretty quick but overall I always come back to this one.

u/thegreatdane1490Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 165

For me, it's always been Maybelline lash sensational sky high mascara. It's pocket-friendly and so so amazing!

u/sarar95Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 63

Truly terrible formulas include Too Faced Better Than Sex, Victoria Beckham mascara, Milk Makeup KUSH, Maybelline Sky High, Essence Lash Princess (shudder to remember), Lancome Monsieur Big.

u/BeeeeDeeeeSentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 54

non-AB Maybelline Sky High Waterproof Mascara (bottom lashes)

u/NiatfqSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 51

I kept repurchasing the ilia mascara! Also Maybelline sky high.

u/SDMAJESTYSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 42

Maybelline Sky High

u/AppropriateMention6Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 34

Currently Showing 10 Reviews