Thrive Mascara

Thrive Causemetics mascara is a popular tubing mascara that offers long-lasting, smudge-free volume and length, easy removal, and is suitable for sensitive eyes and oily lids.

See Product

We may earn a small commission if you click our link. It helps support the cost of running our analysis and keeping this site independent.

Rankings by Sentiment Analysis

Reddit Rank

Total Upvotes

306

Editorial Summary: Thrive mascara is a go-to tubing mascara that many love for its all-day wear and easy removal but watch out for fakes online and some say the formula changed and flakes now. It's a bit pricey but great if you want no smudge and sensitive eye-friendly.

Pros

✓Highly praised tubing mascara, easy to remove without smudging
✓Effective lengthening and volumizing, lasts all day without flaking
✓Good for sensitive eyes and won’t cause raccoon eyes
✓Clean look with no smudging, suitable for oily lids and watery eyes
✓Vegan, cruelty-free, and has a good rewards program

Cons

✗Counterfeit products common on Amazon and third-party sellers
✗Formula may have changed, causing flaking and irritation for some
✗Can be pricey compared to drugstore alternatives
✗Some users find it clumpy or heavy, not suitable for all lash types
✗Requires proper removal technique to avoid irritation

Methodology: We analyzed 91 Reddit quotes from multiple beauty-related subreddits including MakeupAddiction, Sephora, and AmazonVine from January 2016 to June 2025, focusing on user experiences, counterfeit concerns, and formulation feedback to create this balanced overview.

Asked by Redditors

Is Thrive mascara safe to buy on Amazon?

No, many fake versions are sold by unauthorized sellers; buy from Thrive's official website.

Does Thrive mascara flake or smudge?

Most users report no flaking or smudging, but some experienced flaking possibly due to formula changes.

Is Thrive mascara suitable for sensitive eyes?

Yes, many users with sensitive eyes find it comfortable and non-irritating.

What type of mascara is Thrive?

It is a tubing mascara that forms tubes around lashes for easy removal without smudging.

How should I remove Thrive mascara?

It should be removed with water or gentle makeup remover to prevent irritation; avoid rubbing with wipes.

Reddit Reviews:

Calculated by the the number of posts or comments that have an opinion on this product

Positive

226

Neutral

Negative

Probably because it’s either very old or fake. If it’s not being offered by thrive cosmetics directly then it’s too risky don’t buy it.

u/Bumble_Hornet_Sentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 80

L’Oréal voluminous, thrive or sigma mascara

u/iknowshitaboutshitSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 68

I looked it up and the cheap listings are being sold by "Shanhao Trading Co." and shipped from China. Most likely these are counterfeit. When you buy makeup from Amazon, you have to make sure it's shipped and sold either directly from Amazon or from the company itself.

u/my600catlifeSentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 47

Never ever buy makeup from Amazon. Even if you buy it from the official seller, the fakes get mixed in and the pickers might give you a dangerous fake instead of the real thing. It's better to find a dupe or save up and get the real thing.

u/vocalfreesiaSentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 45

Thrive! Love love love love it!

u/hap_hap_happy_feelzSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 34

Unfortunately Sephora doesn't carry thrive cosmetics. That is my favorite tubing mascara.

u/jbriggsstuffSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 31

I really like Thrive, it’s inexpensive and works well. Right now I’m using Tartelette tubing mascara from Tarte and it’s easier to wash off than Thrive, so I think I’m going to reorder this when it’s time.

u/StarryEyes007Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 30

While the Title, Photos, and Information matched Thrive, the seller was NOT Thrive.

u/[OP]Sentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 21

I have to say, Thrive has been the biggest disappointment. It's clumpy, and by far leaves the biggest flakes under my eyes. even when I only use it on my top lashes, I end the day with it flaking under my eyes still.

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 21

I’ve tried them all too and Thrive causemetics is the only one I use now. I buy it when it’s on sale because that brand is pretty pricey.

u/sweetana89Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 16

Currently Showing 10 Reviews