Cotz Prime and Protect Tinted

Cotz Prime and Protect Tinted is a mineral sunscreen that offers solid sun protection with a matte finish, minimal white cast for many, and works well under makeup, though it can be drying for some skin types.

See Product

We may earn a small commission if you click our link. It helps support the cost of running our analysis and keeping this site independent.

Rankings by Sentiment Analysis

Reddit Rank

Total Upvotes

159

Editorial Summary: So this mineral sunscreen mostly blends well and isn’t sticky, but watch out if you’re super pale since white cast can be a thing. Some folks find it drying or flaky, so dry-skin peeps might want extra moisturizer. Works solid under makeup and has a nice matte finish. Just be sure you’re not buying a fake one!

Pros

✓Blends well with minimal white cast for many skin tones
✓Feels non-sticky and works well under makeup
✓Has a matte finish preferred by some users
✓Moisturizing and protective for body use
✓Tint provides subtle coverage without looking unnatural

Cons

✗Common white cast issue, especially on very pale skin
✗Can leave skin feeling dry or flaky
✗Insufficient hydration for very dry skin
✗Difficult to rub in fully without streaks
✗Some users report breakouts or irritation

Methodology: Analyzed 28 quotes from Reddit communities including 30PlusSkinCare, Sephora, SkincareAddiction, and traderjoes between June 2015 and June 2025, focusing on user experiences with texture, finish, white cast, and skin compatibility.

Asked by Redditors

Does this mineral sunscreen leave a white cast?

It may leave a white cast, especially on very pale skin, but many users find it minimal or disappear with rubbing.

Can this product be used under makeup?

Yes, it works well under makeup and has a matte finish preferred by some users.

Is this sunscreen moisturizing?

It offers some moisturizing benefits but may feel drying on very dry skin, so additional moisturizer might be needed.

Is the tint suitable for all skin tones?

The tint blends well on many skin tones without an unnatural look, but results vary.

Are there any issues with fake products?

Yes, fake versions exist with different smell and packaging; authenticity is important for safety and effectiveness.

Reddit Reviews:

Calculated by the the number of posts or comments that have an opinion on this product

Positive

Neutral

Negative

For mineral, cotz prime and protect is fantastic and sticks really well to the skin (especially nose). Neither of these feel sticky on the skin and work pretty well in their own or with makeup. I would also definitely recommend a wide brimmed hat and sunglasses too for extra coverage.

u/giraffee125Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 77

Only chemical spf’s don’t have white casts, this is mineral

u/OrchidwalkerSentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 37

How much did you use? I’ve never gotten a white cast from this one that didn’t disappear with more rubbing in

u/WillowTea_Sentiment: likely neutral Upvotes: 27

I actually like this a lot and thought the white cast was quite minimal. I’m Asian and tanned and have a hard time finding mineral sunscreen that doesn’t leave a white cast. I do however, always put on moisturizer before sunscreen. Maybe that combination works out well?

u/PopcornandCommentsSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 26

I didn’t have issues with lingering white cast and I kinda liked the texture (similar to a pore filling primer) however it made my skin feel quite dry

u/ikeamonkey2Sentiment: likely neutral Upvotes: 15

That’s interesting! I used it on my son and was amazed by how easily it blended in without leaving a white cast.

u/whimsicalsillySentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 14

I couldn’t find the supergoop dupe last time I was there and I had to get this and I hate it.

u/emeraldstar444Sentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 13

I’m as fair as fair can be and still avoid most mineral sunscreens - they all leave a white cast unless I want to spend an hour rubbing it in. They tend to work well, though.

u/blahhhhhhhhhhhblahSentiment: likely neutral Upvotes: 12

Hey, tried this stuff last year. When I went back to get more I couldn't find it and kinda forgot about it. Thanks for the reminder, glad you found something you like.

u/Traditional_Ad_1547Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 12

I’m so pale I glow in the dark and it left a white cast on me :( PS: yes I waited for it to absorb and it still left a cast on my face.

u/Shreddy_Spaghett1Sentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 12

Currently Showing 10 Reviews