Mascara

Reddit Rankings (by upvotes)

96 discussions analyzed

...

R/30PlusSkinCare: Mascara without the raccoon eyes 28 Jun 2025
R/30PlusSkinCare: Finally found a routine that works for me! - 34 yrs old 08 Jun 2025
R/30PlusSkinCare: Farmacy green clean not taking off mascara?! Alternatives? 07 Aug 2023
R/AmazonVine: Counterfeit …. A fake Thrive Mascara popped up today 23 Feb 2025
R/AsianBeauty: My holy grail mascara! (Canmake Metalook Mascara) 10 Jun 2025
R/AsianBeauty: First time using Clio Kill Lash 18 May 2025
R/AsianBeauty: Rave/Review Judydoll 3D Curling Mascara - before and after 14 Feb 2025
R/AsianBeauty: My AB Makeup 12 Feb 2025
R/AsianBeauty: your favourite mascaras for a natural lifted look? 15 Nov 2024
R/AsianBeauty: Unpopular Opinion: Heroine Make Mascara is better than Clio Kill Lash 11 Nov 2024
R/AsianBeauty: My Eid Makeup Routine in Tropical Climate (during 'Summer') 12 Apr 2024
R/AsianBeauty: Mascara review with pictures 29 Feb 2024
R/AsianBeauty: CLIO kill lash superproof mascara or HEROINE MAKE by KissMe? 27 Jan 2024
R/AsianBeauty: Favourite AB purchases of 2023? 13 Nov 2023
R/AsianBeauty: [First Impression Review] Cezanne Lasting Curl Mascara: a mascara that REAAALLY holds a curl!!! 02 Apr 2023
R/AsianBeauty: [Review] Dolly Wink Volume Mascara 06 Mar 2023
R/AsianBeauty: Comparing 3 popular asian mascaras + non-AB recommendations 19 Dec 2022
R/AsianBeauty: Brown mascara AB review: Rom&nd mascara and Heroine Kiss me mascara 23 Jul 2022
R/AsianBeauty: Heroine Make Long and Curl Mascara after 10 hours, a flash typhoon, and a trip to the beach 04 Jul 2021
R/AsianBeauty: Heroine Make Long and Curl Mascara vs CLIO Kill Lash Superproof Mascara 21 Jun 2021
R/AsianBeauty: CLIO Kill Lash Superproof Mascara Long Curling 20 Jun 2021
R/AsianBeauty: Etude House Lash Perm Curl Fix Mascara does👏not👏mess👏around! 19 Mar 2020
R/AsianBeauty: Asian mascaras are the best! (Kiss Me Heroine Long and Curl) 02 Dec 2018
R/AsianBeauty: [Discussion] Anyone else feel that they have a makeup immune face? I will probably struggle with mascara + lip products my whole life 26 Jun 2018
R/AsianBeauty: [Discussion] Removing Heroine Make Mascara 30 Aug 2017
R/AsianBeauty: Heroine Make Advanced Film Mascara ad- Beautifully ridiculous at all times. 09 Jun 2016
R/AsianBeauty: What is your HG mascara? 07 Jan 2016
R/beauty: Best mascara you’ve used? 18 Mar 2025
R/beautytalkph: I did my own grad shoot makeup! 🥳 20 Jun 2025
R/beautytalkph: Korean Idol Lash Style with Clio Kill Lash Long Curling Mascara 08 Oct 2024
R/beautytalkph: Brutally Honest Reviews of Budget-Friendly Makeup from a Broke College Student 26 Aug 2024
R/beautytalkph: I finally found the perfect mascara (at least for me) + 14hrs wear test 06 Aug 2024
R/beautytalkph: Heroine Make Mascara 01 Aug 2024
R/beautytalkph: break-up proof, cheater-proof, miracle in cell no.7-proof mascara ♡ 02 Jul 2024
R/beautytalkph: The OG Heroine Make Eye makeup 19 May 2024
R/drugstoreMUA: Mascara like Maybelline Sky High that doesn't smudge??? 14 Jul 2024
R/drugstoreMUA: How does the regular L'Oreal Telescopic Mascara compare to the waterproof version? 11 Jul 2022
R/KoreanBeauty: everyday mascara 26 May 2025
R/KoreanBeauty: korean mascara and eyeliner recs for oily eyelids? 21 Apr 2025
R/KoreanBeauty: Help Me Build an Asian Beauty Skincare and Makeup Routine (Budget: around $150) 11 Jan 2025
R/KoreanBeauty: Asian Beauty Skincare and Makeup 11 Jan 2025
R/KoreanBeauty: Western version of Clio Kill Lash mascara 02 Dec 2024
R/KoreanBeauty: Removing ROM&ND Han All Fix Mascara / mascara mascara 22 Jul 2024
R/KoreanBeauty: FF going to Seoul soon, what should I get? 12 Jul 2024
R/KoreanBeauty: [REVIEW] KISSME HEROINE LONG & CURL MASCARA ADVANCED FILM SUPER WATERPROOF 16 May 2021
R/KoreanBeauty: Does anyone know of any great oil-based cleansers that will remove Etude House's Curl Fix Mascara? 01 Apr 2021
R/Makeup: High end mascaras are a scam. 29 Apr 2025
R/Makeup: is the loreal telescopic application supposed to look like this? 18 Apr 2025
R/Makeup: Is the essence lash princess waterproof mascara good? 25 Mar 2025
R/Makeup: Drugstore mascara? 22 Mar 2025
R/Makeup: Is the Maybelline Sky High Mascara worth the hype? 04 Apr 2024
R/Makeup: Still searching for the tubing mascara holy grail- and Thrive is NOT it 10 Dec 2023
R/Makeup: What mascara do you swear by? 08 Sept 2023
R/Makeup: What mascara do you swear by? 08 Sept 2023
R/Makeup: 3 year review of thrive mascara 05 May 2023
R/Makeup: Loreal Telescopic Lift 21 Jan 2023
R/Makeup: Why is Thrive mascara so cheap on Amazon? 25 Nov 2022
R/Makeup: Thrive tubing mascara vs Benefit They're Real 31 Oct 2022
R/Makeup: Thoughts on Thrive makeup 12 Feb 2022
R/MakeupAddiction: Do y’all have any CC for my default “full glam” face? I like how I look in it well enough but I also feel like it feels somehow… disjointed or lacking cohesion or something like that? 25 Jun 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: DIY wedding makeup trial 1 - looking for thoughts 09 Jun 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: basic makeup vampy lip 30 Mar 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: do I suit cool tone or warm tone makeup better ? (Pic 1= cool, 2=warm) 15 Mar 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: I drew my everyday makeup routine! 14 Mar 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: Hamster approved basic glam (swipe for pics w/ hammie 🐹) 06 Mar 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: my attempt at blonde bombshell makeup :DD 05 Feb 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: Best mascara you’ve ever used? 12 Jan 2025
R/MakeupAddiction: Cherry Cola All Drugstore Makeup 18 Dec 2024
R/MakeupAddiction: Tubing mascaras: Alleyoop vs Thrive 30 Oct 2024
R/MakeupAddiction: Clio kill lash mascara 07 Sept 2024
R/MakeupAddiction: my makeup before + after 13 hours of flying 27 Aug 2024
R/MakeupAddiction: What is your MUST have mascara 04 Jun 2024
R/MakeupAddiction: Impossible to remove Loreal Telescopic waterproof mascara 29 Dec 2023
R/MakeupAddiction: What’s your holy grail mascara? 18 Sept 2023
R/MakeupAddiction: Suggestions for strongest waterproof eye makeup remover? 10 Mar 2023
R/MakeupAddiction: My holy grail mascara—heroine make long and curl mascara 22 Dec 2017
R/makeupflatlays: The products I use in every look, my ride or dies 🫡 21 Dec 2023
R/muacjdiscussion: Makeup products that make you irrationally angry 24 Mar 2023
R/Sephora: Tubing Mascara Recommendations 27 Jun 2025
R/Sephora: Best brown mascaras? (that are ACTUALLY brown) 11 Jun 2025
R/Sephora: desperate for a mascara that will hold a curl 09 Jun 2025
R/Sephora: which mascara would you pick? 06 Jun 2025
R/Sephora: Glow without glitter 21 May 2025
R/Sephora: Mascara holy grail? 23 Mar 2025
R/Sephora: All-time favorite mascara? 15 Jul 2024
R/Sephora: Yes/no to Tarte’s Tubing Mascara? 08 Jun 2024
R/Sephora: What’s your most favourite mascara and why? 26 Feb 2024
R/Sephora: Unpopular opinion: Expensive mascara is worth it 24 Oct 2023
R/Sephora: Mascara recommendations for gals with straight downward facing eyelashes - please! 05 Oct 2023
R/Sephora: What mascara is good? 18 Aug 2023
R/Sephora: Best makeup remover for sensitive skin? 01 Aug 2023
R/Sephora: What is the most dispointing makeup you ever bought? 30 Jun 2023
R/Sephora: Best make up remover for waterproof mascara? :) 21 May 2023
R/Sephora: Best makeup remover for super waterproof mascara? 17 Aug 2022
R/Sephora: What was your go to mascara this year? 01 Jan 2022
R/Skincare_Addiction: Help! Eyelash care after mascara 23 Aug 2023

Loreal Telescopic Waterproof Mascara

🟢 94 positive reviews
🟡 31 neutral reviews
🔴 30 negative reviews

Essence Lash Princess (Multiple Variants)

🟢 118 positive reviews
🟡 31 neutral reviews
🔴 48 negative reviews

Maybelline Sky High Mascara

🟢 129 positive reviews
🟡 44 neutral reviews
🔴 37 negative reviews

glossier lash stick

🟢 87 positive reviews
🟡 16 neutral reviews
🔴 25 negative reviews

Clio Kill Lash Superproof Mascara (Multiple Variants)

🟢 131 positive reviews
🟡 23 neutral reviews
🔴 39 negative reviews

Thrive Mascara

🟢 226 positive reviews
🟡 38 neutral reviews
🔴 68 negative reviews

Heroine Make Mascara

🟢 217 positive reviews
🟡 40 neutral reviews
🔴 55 negative reviews